Robert Goodman: If you're using washing soda, the only reason to add the less-alkaline
baking soda would be to moderate the former's alkalinity, but if you're
using too much alkali in general, as in this and similar popular recipes,
it's much better to simply cut it down. Best would be to use no more soda
than necessary to neutralize the "hardness" in a load of the wash water,
but that takes an analysis ot fhe water and the amount of water the wash
Kara Kay: This became a bother to make. It cleaned great, but ate hole in my Cotton
prefolds that had urine on them. This recipe is SOOO acidic and so is urine
it would just deteriorate.
Kara Kay: Thank you. Yes. I did not know my chemistry with this recipe. :)
Kara Kay: I haven't . I'll try thx.
Kara Kay: How you liking youtube?
Robert Goodman: Of the 3 brands of soap used above, Kirk's (not Kirklands) is the strongest
because it's all coconut soap, and nothing is to be gained in terms of
strength by mixing it with Ivory. Fels "Naptha" soap no longer contains
naptha, although it may have undisclosed ingredients to improve its
detergency, trade secret, probably BS.
Kara Kay: I do . :)
Kara Kay: This recipe proved to be too strong for diapers.
Kara Kay: LoL.. I appreciate the comment, but I don't really need to be professional
as I am not selling anything nor am I trying to be anything other than
myself. this is youtube. I am not applying for a job. I am just a chick in
her kitchen exploring ways to do things on my own and save money and
sharing that journey with whoever wants to follow. No I don't know anything
about chemistry and have learned much since this video was posted. Thx
again, but spare the personal preference criticisms plz.
SoulGlowActivater01: Blessed be? Idk if you follow thats why I put question mark
MrsDarthDuckie: How well did it work? I'm looking for a new recipe for my laundry, and a
new cloth diaper recipe.
Kara Kay: Thank you Robert! I no nothing of Chemistry and didn't know any of this
when making this recipe. I no longer use it.. What's your opinion of 1 cup
baking soda, 1 cup washing soda and 1 cup oxy clean? I found that recipe on
a cloth diaper site that they say is super safe for diapers..
Robert Goodman: In VERY "hard" water, best not to try to "soften" it completely with
carbonate (washing soda), because the resulting strong alkalinity and chalk
will be destructive to fabric. So large doses of alkali are either
unnecessary or destructive. Silicates were found to be much better with
laundry soap, and complex phosphates even better, in terms of cleaning
fabric as well as not doing damage to fabrics & washing machine parts.
76irodriguez: What you mean by "too strong for diapers? Could you elaborate?
clara17uk: i think B>P white above should act more grown up,than acting like a child
who got a chemistry set for xmas,most things we know today came from
experimenting and lots of mistakes,i would ignore people like him ,hes
trying to be professional comment on a you tube video showed what a nerd he
is ,its you tube not the shopping channel
androshi: have you tried ammonia for your mixture? it works pretty well on tough
Tanyia48: love this ♥
76irodriguez: Instead, you can use 1 cup of washing soda and 1 cup of borax and shred a
baby friendly soap bar and dissolve it all in hot water. Also, if you want
a nice softener, you can use your distilled vinegar in your rinse cycle.
That is what I use when making my laundry detergents. TIP: Distilled
Vinegar is also a great rinse for your hair and for your dogs too. I use it
for my dog all the time and everybody loves the shine and softness of my
pups fur :-)
Kara Kay: Thank you. Yea I am no chemistry buff at all. Just experimenting to find
Kara Kay: Yes, blessed be :)
Kara Kay: Thanks, hope it's still working out.
treemama meg: I did this once, make my own that is, but like you it wasn't cutting it and
making our clothes fresh and white. I might just have to use your recipe,
but tweak it a bit. I don't think we have those bars of soap where I live
in Canada. Maybe some Dr. Bronners bar of soap may work too. I LOVE borax
though, use it on my cloth diapers all the time.
Kara Kay: Ahh. Thanks
Robert Goodman: There's so much wrong, the format here doesn't give enough space to explain
why. Several of the ingredients partly or entirely cancel each other. The
vinegar and alkali counteract, plus either of them will cause most of the
peroxide to be destroyed quickly. If one brand of soap is better than
others, mixing 3 different ones isn't going to give you the best of each.
Like all of these recipes, way too much alkali, so no wonder it eats thru
fabrics. Just use soap with a PINCH of alkali.
Yevon McSteven: The vinegar reacts with the soda and turns into sodium acetate and carbon
dioxide. In other words, the vinegar is useless in the recipe. Basic
76irodriguez: This is very typical. I mean the thought of: "if some is good, a lot is
better". Chemistry is a science that proves very interesting, but you have
to really investigate about your ingredients before you mix them. Some of
this ingredients you are using will work by raising the ph levels in the
water making it more acid, while others will make it drop making it more
alkaline. The Washing Soda alone brings the ph very high but the vinegar
will make it drop, etc. Study them better for your next time
Robert Goodman: Extra alkali have sometimes been added to soap powder & other detergents to
cheapen them, but those are inferior products. For a while "borax" even
became slang for cheap, inferior goods. Hydrogen peroxide is unstable and
should not be mixed with other ingredients in advance. If you want it to
have an effect on laundry, add it separately. Mixing it in advance, a lot
will be destroyed, so although some of it will still be in the mix when you
use it, it's wasteful that way.
Robert Goodman: Why make a video, when it's so much faster to read & write? (Besides, the
audio stopped working on this laptop a few weeks ago.) "Alkali" here refers
to the borax, washing soda, and baking soda. The soap is alkaline too, but
generally is not referred to as alkali in a context like this. Good laundry
soap is mostly soap. It can have added alkali, but should not have much.
Extra alkali degrade fabrics faster. Vinegar is acid, and acid & alkali
neutralize each other, so they're silly to combine.
Kara Kay: Mine lasted for a month or so, but I have switched to powder now.
Robert Goodman: By "BS" I meant bull crap, not baking soda.
Indiana Giordani: Your name is so nostalgic to me, I grew up in a home heated by kerosene,
haha. I want to ask you: How long does this mixture last? As in if I were
looking to make this as a concentrate would any of the ingredients go bad
or would it last as long as I kept it?
drywallit43: whats with yr lighting u live in a cave????
76irodriguez: If I may take this one, I would say that the thing about the baking soda is
that is weaker than washing soda when it comes to their purpose here, which
is to make the water more alkaline so that you have "softer water" to clean
with. So for that alone I would take out the baking soda. (but if you don't
have washing soda you could convert baking soda into washing soda by
76irodriguez: The vinegar is best used as a softener in the rinse cycle.
Belinda Waldron: Love your video!....I to had problems with the detergent not being strong
enough. So I started experimenting with it and did some research on
it.....now it's great I love it!....I have seen other recipes and they were
all about the same. There was pro's and con's bout it...My clothes smell
clean and fresh. And I use distilled white vinegar for my softner it's
great!!!...Look forward to more video's!...Buy the way love your
Kara Kay: Because it's insanely less expensive!!! And much less chemicals. :)
CarneLoba: Why did you choose to make laundry detergent when they sell it made ?
B.P. White: Totally agree with Robert Goodman & 76irodriguez; you have to know how each
ingredient is going to react with the other ingredients regardless of what
you are making. One of the basic rules of chemistry, if you took chemistry.
Poor quality video also, and you could have taken out the lip ring and
especially the snout ring! Try being professional.